US

Jury ends Day 2 of Samsung-Apple deliberations

SAN JOSE, Calif. (AP) — Silicon Valley jurors failed to reach a decision Wednesday and will return for a third day of deliberations to determine how much Samsung Electronics owes Apple for copying key features of the iPhone and iPad.

A previous jury found Samsung guilty of infringing several Apple patents in making and marketing 26 devices, and it ordered Samsung to pay $1.05 billion. But U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh tossed out $450 million of those damages and ordered the new jury to recalculate damages for 13 of the devices.

Apple is demanding $380 million. Samsung says it only owes $52 million. The judge on Wednesday also refused Samsung's second request in as many days to halt the trial. The latest request was made after patent regulators questioned the validity of one of Apple's patents that Samsung was found to have infringed.

The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office was "re-examining" Apple's patents for the pinch-to-zoom function on its phones and tablets. Apple has said it is the most commercially valuable of the three software patents at issue in the trial.

The office said Wednesday that Apple's arguments in support of the patent "are not persuasive." The office didn't invalidate the patent, but it ordered Apple to submit more evidence to support it. Even if the patent office invalidates the patent, it remains valid through the long appeals process that could reach the U.S. Supreme Court.

The San Jose federal courtroom is a 15-minute drive from Apple Inc.'s Cupertino headquarters, and several prospective jurors were dismissed because of their ties to the company. Lawyers for South Korean-based Samsung Electronics Co. complained to the judge Tuesday that when Apple attorney Harold McIhenny told the jury that U.S. television makers were driven out of business for failing to protect their intellectual property, it was an unfair attempt to inflame jurors' prejudices.

Judge Koh denied Samsung's demand for a mistrial, but she did call jurors back from deliberations to reread an instruction ordering them to put aside their dislikes and biases in deciding the case. The two companies are locked in legal battles around the globe for supremacy in the more than $300 billion smartphone market.

Related Headlines

  • Jury orders Samsung to pay Apple $290 million

    A Silicon Valley jury on Thursday added $290 million more to the damages Samsung Electronics owes Apple for copying vital iPhone and iPad features, bringing the total amount ... 

  • Harold McIlhenny

    Samsung says it owes Apple $52 million

    How much does Samsung Electronics owe Apple for copying vital features of the iPhone and iPad? Apple says $380 million. Samsung counters with $52 million. It's possible a jury ... 

  • Samsung: Patents developed by Google engineers

    Samsung fired back at Apple's accusations of patent theft Tuesday, saying the South Korean tech giant didn't write any of the Android software on its smartphones and tablets, ... 

  • BlackBerry wins ruling against iPhone keyboard

    Troubled smartphone maker BlackBerry has won an early round in its legal battle against an iPhone keyboard made by a startup co-founded by "American Idol" host Ryan Seacrest. 

Find your future job here