United raised the stakes on Wednesday when it announced that it will retrofit more than 100 planes as part of a move to add 1,600 premium seats on nearly 250 jets. The airline also plans to start using a new 50-seat jet with mostly premium seats on some routes popular with business travelers.
The decision is part of a larger industry trend to give more space and better service to high-paying passengers who account for a disproportionate share of airline revenue. Andrew Nocella, United's chief commercial officer, said executives decided that the airline has "a shortage of business-class seats into the premium markets, and this fixed that problem."
"It helps our customers and it helps our bottom line," he said. Henry Harteveldt, an airline analyst at Atmosphere Research, said United's announcement was a bold challenge to Delta Air Lines, the acknowledged front-runner among the nation's top three carriers for its on-time performance and strong profit margins.
"This is big news. They are taking direct aim at Delta and its strength with premium travelers," Harteveldt said. Delta executives say they have increased premium seating from 9 percent to nearly 30 percent since 2011, and they're selling more than 60 percent of those seats, up from 13 percent — not just giving them away in the form of upgrades. They say more corporate accounts are letting employees buy up to premium travel.
As a result, one-third of Delta's revenue now comes from premium services and less than half comes from economy seating, down from nearly two-thirds in 2011, senior vice president of pricing Eric Phillips said in December.
American has added "premium economy" seats — often double the price of regular economy but less than business class — on many planes used for international flights. United will retrofit 21 of its Boeing 767-300ER jets starting in the next several weeks. It will reduce seats from 214 to 167 by shrinking the economy section while going from 30 to 46 business-class seats and adding 22 "premium plus" seats. The planes will fly first between United's hub in Newark, New Jersey, and London.
Nocella dismissed the idea that sharply reducing the number of economy seats will result in higher fares for budget-conscious customers. He said the airline could add flights across the Atlantic to maintain the supply of economy seats, and vowed that United would not surrender any group of customers to rival carriers.
United also plans to add a few more first-class seats to its Airbus A319 and A320 planes. By year end, it hopes to begin using new 50-seat Bombardier CRJ 550 jets between Chicago and smaller markets with many business travelers, such as Bentonville, Arkansas, the home of Walmart. Federal regulators have not yet certified the plane, which will be operated by GoJet Airlines under the United Express brand name.
Small, 50-seat planes are notoriously cramped and unpopular with many travelers. Nocella said United's new small planes — 18 feet (6 meters) longer than the comparable plane it uses now — will have 10 business-class seats, 20 "economy plus" seats and only 20 regular economy seats.
"By making those 50-seat jets more comfortable, United has a good chance of attracting more business and frequent flyers," said Harteveldt, the analyst. But business travel is contingent on a strong economy and fortunes could change should there be a recession.
Nocella said reconfiguration decisions are based on long-term expectations, and he is not worried that a recession could dent business-travel demand, which he said has remained strong. Chicago-based United is the nation's third-biggest airline by revenue, trailing American and Delta.
David Koenig can be reached at http://twitter.com/airlinewriter