Cittadella had been hoping to earn promotion to the top flight of Italian soccer for the first time in its history after winning Thursday's first leg 2-0. However, Mattia Zaccagni got Verona firmly back into the playoff in the first half and Samuel Di Carmine doubled his side's lead in the 69th minute, shortly after Cittadella midfielder Luca Parodi had been sent off for a second booking.
That result would have seen Verona promoted as it finished the regular season fifth, a point ahead of seventh-place Cittadella. In the event of a draw, away goals do not count, there is no extra time and the side that finished in a higher position earns promotion.
Cittadella went down to nine men in the 77th when midfielder Federico Proia was also shown a second yellow card and Karim Laribi scored a third goal six minutes later. The other promoted sides are Serie B champion Brescia and runner-up Lecce.
More AP soccer: https://apnews.com/apf-Soccer and https://twitter.com/AP_Sports